“Time doesn’t exist.” “Time is an illusion created by the brain.” Statements like these sound vaguely profound.
I might once have accepted them as another possible way of thinking. Recently, though, thinking about aging led me to relativity, then to another question.
I described that route in “An unexpected resemblance between aging and relativity”.
What does “time” mean in the particular claim being made?
I’m not rejecting specific theories of time in physics or philosophy. This comes before that.
The sentence “time doesn’t exist” alone may leave us unable to tell what has been denied.
What do we look at to tell the time?
We routinely say three hours have passed, it’s evening, or a year has gone by.
We aren’t looking directly at time itself. We look at clock hands and digits, dates, the sun’s position, approaching darkness, and changing seasons.
Spring becomes summer, leaves fall, winter comes, and spring returns. Such changes let us judge how much time has passed.
Looking inside a clock doesn’t change that. A pendulum clock uses swings, a quartz clock uses quartz oscillations, and an atomic clock uses a regular periodic phenomenon involving atoms.
Very roughly, we measure one change against another. In daily life, we treat the resulting measure of duration as time.
Nothing especially mysterious so far. Yet different things have already begun entering the same word.
There is elapsed time measured by clocks, the duration someone feels, and something like time itself assumed to exist separately from matter and change.
All are called time, but they aren’t the same discussion.
What is “time doesn’t exist” denying?
If someone says time doesn’t exist, my first question is which time they mean.
When I say three hours passed, I’m not claiming a transparent substance called time exists somewhere in the universe and three hours of it flowed past. I mean roughly that the clock advanced three hours.
If someone then denies time itself flowing independently of matter, and that is the thing they call time, I wasn’t discussing it in the first place.
“Time exists” and “No, it doesn’t” may look opposed while the speakers simply use the word for different things.
Before asking whether time exists, it would be better to establish what the word refers to.
Is time an illusion created by the brain?
I often see that expression too. Comments commonly agree that enjoyable hours fly by while boring hours feel endless.
If time here means the subjective feeling of its passage, an explanation involving the brain is understandable. The same hour can feel long or short depending on what we’re doing.
What bothers me is extending that claim in one leap to say clock-measured elapsed time or time in physics is also an illusion.
How time feels and what happens externally aren’t identical questions.
Does food itself change when hunger changes its taste?
The same food feels different when I’m hungry and when I’m full. A delicious meal while hungry may be unappealing on a full stomach.
I wouldn’t normally conclude that the meal’s ingredients or physical state changed to match my appetite. The change may be in the person receiving it.
A luxury hotel offers a similar example. Someone who has lived in restrictive conditions for a long time may value a room very differently from someone accustomed to a mansion and first-class hotels.
One may see heaven while the other sees nothing special. They’re still looking at the same room.
The same thing can feel different according to the recipient’s condition. Isn’t that ordinary human experience?
What does time flying while we enjoy ourselves show?
Moving from an enjoyable hour feeling short to time being a brain-created illusion therefore seems, by itself, a leap.
What the example directly shows is that our sense of duration changes with our state.
In the same room, one person is absorbed in a game while another has nothing to do. After three hours, one asks whether it’s already been that long; the other asks whether it’s only been that long.
The clocks beside them have advanced equally.
In this example, at least, the difference is in the people experiencing the duration, not the elapsed time recorded.
The phenomenon could instead be read as evidence that humans aren’t accurate instruments for sensing time.
When experience changes, what changed?
This applies beyond time. When something feels different, did the object change, or did the person experiencing it change?
Perception is strongly affected by physical state, recent experience, and comparisons. Hunger affects how food tastes, and familiar surroundings affect how we judge a room.
So a change in subjective duration alone warrants caution before drawing conclusions about clocks or time in physics.
A changed experience doesn’t by itself establish that its object is an illusion. Connecting the two needs further explanation.
What would time flowing mean in a world without change?
Then I considered something more extreme.
Imagine a world where nothing changes: no change in matter, no events, clocks, sunrise, or seasons. It remains exactly the same.
Suppose I say ten billion years passed there. What differs between that world at zero seconds and ten billion years later?
A clock in another, external world could measure ten billion years. But what that establishes is ten billion years of change in the external world, with no observable change in this one.
Adding that time itself nevertheless flowed for ten billion years in the unchanged world requires positing time existing separately from change.
Then I wonder: what distinguishes a world with that time itself from a world without it?
If there’s no observable difference, I at least don’t know how to distinguish them.
I’m not therefore declaring time nonexistent. That would let me define the word arbitrarily and extend the conclusion myself.
What I can say is only that I currently see no way to distinguish those two cases.
Ultimately, what does “time” refer to?
After thinking this through, the binary question of existence or nonexistence interests me less.
Checking what is being called time comes first.
Clock-measured duration? Felt duration? Units of seconds, minutes, and years? Time in physics? Or something independently flowing through the universe apart from matter and change?
Quite different things occupy one word.
The brain producing our subjective sense of time isn’t the same claim as clock-measured duration being illusory.
Humans inventing seconds and years as units isn’t the same as humans inventing the physical phenomena measured with those units.
Bundling everything into the word time hides these distinctions.
I described returning to the specific claim rather than being impressed by terminology or the weight of a discipline in “Being told it was metaphysics made me investigate—and that was what fell apart”.
I ended up somewhere quite simple.
Clock hands, digits, calendars, the sun, day and night, seasons: people have long measured time using some kind of change.
If that is what we call time, it isn’t particularly mysterious.
But introduce a different concept afterward—time itself flowing through the universe independently of matter—deny it, and announce that time doesn’t exist, and my response is:
Weren’t we discussing different things from the start?


コメント