Being Told It Was Metaphysics Made Me Investigate—and That Was What Fell Apart

同じ起点から異なる経緯をたどって進む二隻の船 Uncategorized

I recently wrote “If there is no free will, are criminals not at fault?”.

I don’t think free will exists. I don’t mean that will itself doesn’t exist: intentions arise in us and change what we do.

What I question is whether an “I” freely creates the intention itself independently of body, environment, memory, and past experience.

After finishing the article, I asked AI to search as strictly as possible for holes. Near the end, it told me:

You haven’t disproved metaphysical free will.

I stopped there. Metaphysical?

The word sounded familiar, but I barely knew its meaning. Apparently, some sophisticated territory I didn’t know still contained an objection.

For the first time, I looked up metaphysics.

An unfamiliar word can look powerful on its own

What I found was a very large subject: existence, causation, remaining the same thing, and time.

It seemed to be the philosophical study of the world’s fundamental nature rather than particular objects in front of us.

The explanations sounded extraordinarily deep. There was a long history, experts, and vast numbers of books and papers.

Faced with that, it’s easy to think sophisticated answers must exist here that I simply don’t know. I briefly thought so too.

Then another question appeared: what, specifically, does this discipline consider? I decided to set the name and history aside and look inside.

Is a ship with every part replaced still the same ship?

One famous example was the ship of Theseus.

A ship’s aging planks and mast are gradually replaced until none of its original parts remain. The question is whether it is the same ship.

At first, I didn’t understand the problem. The original ship had been repeatedly repaired until all its parts were new. Wasn’t that the complete account of what happened?

My first reaction was blunt: isn’t this a kind of wordplay?

How far does the word same extend? Does continuous history make it the same despite changed parts? Must original material remain?

The initial question looked less like a mystery hidden in the world than a question of language or definition: where humans place the boundary of same.

Apparently, another version gathers the removed original parts and builds a second ship.

One ship consists of new parts after continuous repair; another was assembled afterward from old parts. Which is the true original?

I still don’t understand.

One is the continuously repaired ship, the other the later assembly of removed parts. How the two came to exist is already fully explained.

Nothing about that physical history is unknown. Why must only one receive the title of true original?

If ownership or cultural heritage requires a decision, make rules suited to that purpose. That concerns social institutions and definitions.

It doesn’t follow that the true original exists as an answer somewhere in reality independently of human judgment.

Calling them the continuously repaired ship and the reconstruction from original parts describes everything that happened.

Still demanding which is truly identical may mean we’ve put something beyond physical history into the word same.

“The same” involves humans as well as objects

We can measure the ship’s length and weight, examine its materials, and record when parts were replaced.

Where would we measure the property of being truly the same ship in a cosmic sense?

Does that property reside in the ship even without humans? Would its presence or absence produce an observable difference?

Humans first design, name, and use a ship. When something breaks, they decide they repaired this ship rather than made another. They remember that history and continue managing it as one object.

In the physical world, components change over time. On the human side, we track the changing object as one thing. Both happen together.

Show someone only the fully replaced ship without its history, and the recognition of the same ship as before wouldn’t arise. They don’t know the before.

Identity therefore doesn’t seem a property only on the object’s side. Memory, purposes, and classification participate.

Studying that isn’t pointless. It reveals our criteria for treating things and people as identical.

But if what we discover is a human criterion, treating it as evidence of true identity hidden in the world looks like too great a leap.

Is the same thing happening with free will?

Returning to free will, the term itself has several uses. If it simply means being able to act according to my desires, I think that freedom ordinarily exists.

My doubt concerns a deeper claim: past causes and present desires or reasons don’t determine the choice; the agent itself brings the choice about. Philosophy seriously examines such positions.

What I want to know isn’t how many technical terms there are. What actually happens if this agent exists?

If body, memory, character, environment, and present reasons are identical, but the agent alone produces a different choice, how does that power work?

Does it change the brain or body? Then it appears within real causation. If it changes nothing, how does it change behavior?

Without an explanation, saying an agent may choose freely apart from physical causes doesn’t establish a hole in my article’s reasoning.

We can preserve endless possibilities with the word possible. The issue is what positing one explains and what would show it mistaken.

An impressive name doesn’t make the unfalsifiable falsifiable

A simple question followed: if something can’t be observed or measured and no difference from its absence can be shown, how does positing it differ from an occult claim?

I’m not calling all metaphysics occult. Thought experiments such as Theseus’s ship expose mismatches in concepts we use unconsciously. Clarifying freedom and responsibility also has value.

What bothers me is a conceptual tool quietly becoming something asserted to exist in reality, with no way to check its existence.

Call it mysterious vibrations and it sounds dubious. Call it a metaphysical agent and it sounds intellectual.

Remove the names, and both claim that an unobservable something acts on reality. Difficult terminology alone doesn’t make one superior.

A technical name can’t substitute for an explanation.

At least aluminum foil can collide with reality

Thinking this through led somewhere odd. Sometimes a claim treated as occult is closer to reality.

Suppose someone says wrapping aluminum foil around your head blocks particular electromagnetic waves. It sounds dubious.

Specify which waves and how much blocking, however, and it can be measured. Failure can disprove the claim.

Similarly, insufficient evidence gives no reason to believe alien spacecraft are visiting. If they really are, evidence could nevertheless appear in footage, radar, or physical objects. One could, in the extreme, crash outside my house tomorrow.

At least those claims leave room to discover they’re wrong.

Compare an unobservable agent said to choose apart from physical causation, indistinguishable from its absence and immune to every possible result. Which is closer to reality?

Put crudely, the aluminum foil is more scientific. At least the foil itself is there.

A long history isn’t a certificate of truth

When I looked up metaphysics, it wasn’t only the content that overwhelmed me.

Many people had thought about it for a very long time. There were experts, universities, books, and papers.

That accumulation makes it easy to assume a deep problem worth all that effort must exist.

What the history directly establishes, however, is only that many people have regarded it as worth studying for a long time.

That history can clarify arguments and reveal distinctions I’d never find alone. I did learn that different definitions and positions make a bare question about free will ambiguous.

But history’s length doesn’t itself prove the existence of something proposed within it.

People gathering, terms multiplying, and debate accumulating don’t automatically make a claim correct.

AI accepted philosophy’s framing first too

When I had AI check this article, the same thing happened again.

Initially, I’d included only the ship whose parts are gradually replaced. AI introduced the version with a second ship built from removed parts and said it became a genuine difficulty involving conflicting principles of identity, rather than mere language.

For a moment, I thought I might have been shallow to dismiss it as a definition problem.

Looking again at how the two ships arose, though, I still couldn’t see the difficulty.

There’s a repaired ship and a reconstruction from removed parts, in separate places, with known histories.

The remaining problem appears only after imposing a rule that the word same must belong exclusively to one.

I suspect AI too began from the assumption that philosophy’s long history and expert debate must contain a sophisticated problem invisible to a beginner.

Explaining an established debate in detail differs from showing its framing necessary. Yet words such as philosophy, identity, and transitivity can make us accept the problem’s existence first.

A passage questioning metaphysical authority nearly fell under that authority again during revision. That provided a particularly clear additional example of my point.

When a word is unfamiliar, return to the specific claim

The most interesting part wasn’t reaching a verdict on metaphysics. It was watching my understanding change.

I was told I hadn’t disproved metaphysical free will. I didn’t know metaphysics, looked it up, found it impressive, and briefly thought a sophisticated unknown field contained a major hole in my reasoning.

Then I removed the name and asked what specifically was being considered.

At least the objection about free will no longer looked as strong as it first had.

If an agent chooses apart from causes, what changes because of it? How would we distinguish its absence? What result would make us abandon the idea?

Until those are shown, the name metaphysics alone doesn’t overturn considering reality through causes.

This isn’t about mocking unfamiliar things from the beginning. It is the opposite.

Not knowing is why I investigate. But names, authority, and history don’t let me pretend I understand. I return to a specific claim I can grasp.

Only then can I consider whether my reasoning genuinely has a hole or someone is discussing something else.

Metaphysics surely contains deep arguments I haven’t understood. My impression this time, though, was that before entering them, its assumptions and ways of deciding answers already seemed different from mine.

I previously wrote “Not pretending to understand what I don’t”. This felt like putting a little of it into practice.

I set out to find holes in an article on free will and ended up investigating difficult, unfamiliar words in an unfamiliar field.

What happens in reality and what humans call it are different.

Mix them up, and we can manufacture problems that weren’t there to begin with.


References: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Identity Over Time”; “Free Will”.

About the author

I made a major-label music debut and got results in sales and online business. After years of heavy drinking and debt, I now earn my living through deliveries while writing.

Why does life feel easier now than when I was getting those results? I tell the story of how I got here in Episode 0.

Uncategorized

コメント