What are we seeing when we call someone strong-willed?

同じ目的地へ進みながら異なる動機に動かされる二人の人物 Uncategorized

“That person has a strong will.”

It’s a familiar expression.

Someone studies early every morning, maintains a strict diet, or works toward one goal for years. We readily call them strong-willed.

I’ve used it normally too, but recently it has begun to feel slightly odd.

What exactly are we seeing when we say that?

Does it hurt them as much as it hurts me?

Suppose studying feels extremely unpleasant to me.

Even an hour at a desk hurts and makes me want something else. Seeing someone study five or ten hours daily, I’d naturally regard them as strong-willed.

But there’s an unverified premise.

Do they find studying as painful as I do?

They might not dislike it much. Learning is interesting, solving problems pleasurable, or improving grades enjoyable. Perhaps it feels much like videos or games feel to me.

If I assume they’re enduring the same pain merely because studying hurts me, then judge their will from that, the claim changes somewhat.

Equal discomfort doesn’t guarantee equal action

Suppose two people feel almost identical discomfort from studying itself.

Both dislike it and want to escape the desk, yet one continues daily and the other stops.

Now the first seems strong-willed. But we still don’t know.

They might deeply fear failing an exam, unemployment, disappointing parents, or losing to classmates. An urgent need to escape their present environment could take them to the desk.

Even with equal study discomfort, differences elsewhere change action.

If studying hurts eighty but the feared future without it hurts a hundred, they may study. If that fear is only twenty, perhaps they’ll stop for today.

Outside, we see only one continuing and one stopping, then label the results strong or weak will.

The behavioral difference may actually emerge from overlapping anxiety, fear, expectation, interest, habit, competitiveness, recognition-seeking, and urgency.

Calling all of that willpower obscures almost everything moving the person.

Ten hours of study is strong will. Ten hours of games rarely is.

There’s another curious point.

Someone studying ten hours daily may be praised for remarkable willpower.

Someone gaming ten hours daily rarely receives the same praise. They may instead be considered too weak-willed to stop.

That’s rather odd.

Both sustain attention on one thing for a long time. Perhaps only one receives praise because a prior value judgment considers studying desirable.

Strong will then describes more than the person’s characteristics. It includes the observer’s evaluation of the action.

Does “they continue because they’re strong-willed” explain anything?

Answering why someone studies daily with “Because they have a strong will” also seems odd.

If a continuing person is what we call strong-willed, it’s little different from saying they continue because they’re someone who continues.

We’ve named it without identifying a cause.

Why can they continue? They may enjoy studying, fear failure, have a habit requiring little decision, vividly imagine success, or have past experience making effort feel likely to pay off.

Only then do we get a little closer to causes.

Willpower is convenient language. When seeking causes, it can be too convenient.

I needn’t define myself as weak-willed either

This isn’t only about observing others.

Study doesn’t last. Exercise doesn’t last. I can’t stop drinking. New activities end after three days.

Repeated enough, those experiences invite the judgment that I’m weak-willed. But the label still explains nothing.

How painful is the activity? How real does its future reward feel? What would stopping lose? Is another desire stronger? Do I actually want the goal at all?

Separating those questions can reveal something other than a defect of personality. Different causes call for different changes.

Perhaps even the ability to make an effort is given beforehand

Go further back and things become troublesome.

Someone is intensely interested in one subject, thinks about it all day, and never tires of it across years.

Outside, it looks like tremendous effort. Inside, they may simply be doing what’s interesting.

Did they create that overwhelming interest through effort?

Some are intensely drawn to music, others mathematics. Others can spend hours considering how businesses work.

They are indeed doing it by their own will. But they didn’t choose what would interest them so strongly.

The line between talent and effort becomes less clear.

Talent may be more than immediate skill. Wanting to continue much longer than others may itself be a talent.

An ability may look earned through effort, yet the intense interest producing the effort may not have been chosen from the start.

Look beyond the label to what moves the person

I’m not saying never to use the expression. In daily conversation, it’s often enough.

But if I genuinely want to know why someone acts that way, stopping at strong will misses a great deal.

Whether they continue or don’t, what draws them toward the activity, and what takes them away?

Recently, I find looking there more interesting.

Follow that question further and I reach who chose the will arising inside the person in the first place.

Beyond that lies free will. I explain my view in “If there is no free will, are criminals not at fault?”.

About the author

I made a major-label music debut and got results in sales and online business. After years of heavy drinking and debt, I now earn my living through deliveries while writing.

Why does life feel easier now than when I was getting those results? I tell the story of how I got here in Episode 0.

Uncategorized

コメント