There is no single right answer: the answer changes with the goal

同じ都市へ向かう二つの異なる道の分岐に立つ人物 Uncategorized

Suppose I say this to someone playing soccer:

“You have hands. Why not pick up the ball? Are you stupid?”

Or say the reverse to someone playing basketball:

“You have feet. Why not kick the ball? Are you stupid?”

Both seem to discuss using hands and feet. Actually, they’re simply playing different sports.

Without checking the aim or rules, one judges the other by a different standard.

It sounds absurd, but I suspect many repeated human arguments aren’t much different.

The right answer can’t be settled first

Recently, I watched a video about people using AI and deliberately not using it.

If the aim is reaching a correct answer quickly, AI is more rational. If the aim is experiencing research, uncertainty, and thought, speed alone isn’t a meaningful comparison.

The two seem to disagree about AI.

Before that, their aims differ.

One wants a quick answer; the other wants to investigate and think personally. Different desires won’t be reconciled through speed alone.

I wrote about that in “What only humans can do in the AI age: not use AI”.

That made something clear again.

What’s right can be determined only after deciding what I want to do.

For reaching Tokyo quickly, the bullet train might be right. For visiting towns along the route, a bicycle might be right.

Neither can be declared superior without stating the purpose.

Before what’s right comes what I want to achieve.

I’d called differences of purpose differences of values

I’ve thought there’s no single correct answer, only versions of justice serving different interests.

That hasn’t changed, but simply saying values differ is vague.

Different values produce different answers.

More concretely, different priorities change both the desired outcome and the route toward it.

Someone wanting a richly natural planet and someone wanting higher living standards may judge the same forest development differently.

Both conservation and prosperity involve a condition someone wants. Neither alone speaks for the Earth’s own will. I examine this in “Is ‘good for the Earth’ really the Earth’s own value judgment?”.

People sometimes present wishes as correctness rather than preference.

That’s where matters become difficult.

Soccer and basketball can remain a joke

Mocking each other’s sporting rules may end in an argument.

When religions and states do something similar, it isn’t funny.

So-called religious wars involve overlapping territory, power, resources, ethnicity, and other factors. Different gods alone don’t explain them.

Still, visions of the eventual society can conflict.

Spread one doctrine throughout society, permit no other faith, or create a society where several faiths coexist.

To someone treating the last aim as obviously correct, imposed belief is wrong. To someone sincerely believing one doctrine saves humanity, allowing other faiths is wrong instead.

People wanting plural faiths and people believing in one truth try to turn their respective visions into laws on the same land.

Soccer and basketball can use separate courts. States and religions may seek to govern the same territory, laws, and people, making their purposes incompatible.

Imposing our own rules on the same land needn’t end with words.

In war, desired end states differ

In current wars too, sides don’t describe their own actions as simple evil.

Protect national security, regain seized territory, achieve independence, restore historical rights, maintain a regime and order.

The words alone can all sound right.

One side’s desired security may conflict with another’s independence. One side’s recovered territory may be the same land as the other’s defended border.

It isn’t merely different opinions about one event. The conditions they want after the war differ.

Sharing all the facts therefore doesn’t guarantee agreement.

Errors and propaganda can sustain war too. But even agreed facts leave conflict when objectives remain incompatible.

Even peace doesn’t necessarily mean the same thing.

Silencing every opponent might remove combat from a city. Some call that restored order and peace; others call it silence through fear.

Both can invoke peace without describing the same state.

What does the war on drugs aim to reduce?

Drug policy offers another clear example.

Aiming to eliminate illegal drug use itself suggests strict controls on possession and sales and deterrence through severe penalties.

Aiming to reduce deaths, infection, crime, and ruined lives suggests connecting users to treatment and support rather than driving them underground.

Both want to improve the drug problem, but one may measure users and supply while the other measures death and health damage.

Arguing punishment versus support without separating those measures misses the point.

Cartels also have objectives.

Profit, organizational survival, territory, and protection of members. Individuals may aim to feed a family. Some may believe they provide order where a corrupt state fails.

Members probably don’t all wake planning pure evil. Joining or obeying may appear rational for survival in those surroundings.

This isn’t entirely imaginary.

Colombia’s Pablo Escobar built housing for poor people and funded hospitals and sports facilities. A criminal organization delivered visible benefits where the state hadn’t provided enough.

Viewed only there, residents’ support isn’t surprising.

Research also reports criminal groups providing food, settling disputes, and creating their own order where residents perceive insufficient state employment or security. Beyond charity, support can discourage informing police and protect the business.

Support and control aren’t opposites. Assistance can gain backing that stabilizes power.

That alone didn’t sustain power over time. Money, jobs, bribery, threats, and murder coexisted. Outside observers can’t neatly separate genuine support from fearful compliance.

A simple division between a protective state and harmful cartels nevertheless fails to explain what occurred.

States have also backed down in actual confrontation. In 2019, Mexican security forces detained Sinaloa Cartel figure Ovidio Guzmán. Large-scale cartel attacks across the city raised the danger to civilians and security personnel, and the government released him.

The cartel hadn’t destroyed the state itself. But in that situation it forced a reversal.

Help residents before the state, build obligations, discourage reports, and if necessary push back state forces: calling such a powerful opponent merely bad people reveals little.

Understanding a cartel’s internal purpose doesn’t make me want to live under its rule.

Understanding someone’s aim and accepting it are different things.

If I genuinely want to stop it, I need to examine why joining became rational rather than end with bad people doing bad things.

Without jobs, amid government corruption, with cartels closer than police and noncompliance threatening family lives, arresting one person leaves conditions for the next.

Looking beyond evil to the causes of offending is also discussed in “If there is no free will, are criminals not at fault?”.

Is state violence automatically just?

It would be easy to end by saying cartel motives don’t make murder or kidnapping right.

But that simply assumes the state’s rules are correct without examining them.

States detain people, kill in wars, and sometimes suppress opponents violently. Fighting may end through that and later peace emerge.

A state seizing someone is called arrest; a cartel doing so is called kidnapping.

Armed order from a state is called public security; from a cartel, rule by fear.

I’m not claiming they’re identical apart from names.

States have laws, courts, and institutions monitoring power. At least in principle, routes remain to contest detention, participate politically, and change laws.

If those mechanisms function, state and cartel detention differ greatly.

But state action doesn’t automatically make violence right.

Laws may favor only some people, courts may fail, and rights to object may be absent.

The title of state or cartel isn’t enough to identify the difference.

Examine aims, whose interests are protected, who is harmed, procedures and objections, possible alternatives, and actual events.

Only then can comparison begin.

Does that make everything right?

Some may infer that if correctness changes with aims, everything becomes right.

No.

Different aims changing answers doesn’t mean every means achieves an aim.

If reducing drug deaths is the goal, investigate which policy actually reduced deaths. For public safety, test whether a policy improved security or increased violence.

Choosing an aim doesn’t let us choose real outcomes however we please.

People decide what to pursue. Actual results show whether the method brought them closer.

Achieving one objective also leaves the separate question of what the method cost.

Killing all opponents might remove visible conflict. If life and freedom also matter, that choice loses them.

Ultimately, we must decide priorities among several aims and what not to sacrifice.

People have to make those priorities.

My chosen standards aren’t absolute either

I prefer a society where I can live without being killed to one where killing is easy to permit.

I prefer laws, procedures, and objections to a state that can detain anyone at will.

I’d prioritize reducing deaths, dependence, and crime over making drug users suffer.

I don’t choose those because they’ve been proved right for everyone.

I choose them because that’s the society I want to live in.

That doesn’t require withdrawing my judgment. Instead of declaring absolute correctness, state what I want to protect and examine what my chosen method produces.

Understand the other’s purpose, then still oppose it if the two are incompatible.

Not exclude something as wrong to every observer, but say I want this society and will stop actions destroying it.

That seems much more honest to me.

Without an aim, there is no settled right answer

Saying only that there’s no right answer sounds like abandoning judgment.

I don’t mean that everything makes the same difference.

We can’t settle the right answer without saying what we’re aiming for.

Once we decide, actual results let us compare which methods helped and which didn’t.

But why choose that aim, and how far may it be imposed on others? People must decide again.

Sometimes arguments put different meanings inside the same word. I’ve explored that in “Before saying time doesn’t exist, ask what time is” and “I investigated metaphysics, and found that side falling apart instead”.

Do aims differ, word meanings differ, or the facts being considered differ? Or are we disputing effective methods toward the same aim?

Separating those at least reveals what the dispute concerns.

Humanity has treated desired conditions as right for everyone, then persuaded, dominated, and sometimes killed to impose them.

Recognizing no universal answer won’t remove conflict. Desired outcomes can remain incompatible.

Still, we needn’t present what we want as right for everyone.

Keep watching what we want to protect, what we do for it, and what actually happens.

That’s why I don’t want to accept something simply because it’s called justice. Who wants what, who benefits, who is harmed? I want to look that far before judging.

The basic positions of Mugen no Hamon, including this one, are collected in CORE.

About the author

I made a major-label music debut and got results in sales and online business. After years of heavy drinking and debt, I now earn my living through deliveries while writing.

Why does life feel easier now than when I was getting those results? I tell the story of how I got here in Episode 0.

Uncategorized

コメント