If there is no free will, are criminals not at fault?

複数の原因から分岐点へ導かれ、危険の手前で青い境界に止められる人物 Uncategorized

I don’t think free will exists. That doesn’t mean I think will itself doesn’t exist.

Hunger produces a wish to eat. Wanting to study leads to studying. Anger produces a wish to say something. Wills arise normally and change action.

What I question is whether an I independent of body, environment, memory, and other causes freely creates that will itself.

Extending that thought to crime raises difficult questions.

If there is no free will, are criminals not at fault? If not, is punishment unnecessary?

Having a will and having free will are different

Suppose I say this to someone with a beloved pet:

Hurt that pet now.

It’s physically possible: hands and tools can move. Yet many people probably couldn’t do it.

A powerful will not to do it exists.

One could say they chose not to hurt it, proving free will.

That isn’t the point I’m questioning.

Without changing their wish not to hurt it, their love, memories, or values, could they choose the harmful action as they are?

Doing it would presumably require another reason: a new motive to prove free will, a huge reward, or believing it necessary to save someone else.

A changed choice has some additional cause before it.

Who chose the wish not to hurt?

Did they decide to become someone who loves their pet?

Further back, how much did they choose their character, parents, upbringing, experiences, physical traits, and sources of fear or pleasure?

Thinking that way, even I sometimes look like a phenomenon to myself.

Of course I can decide not to eat for health despite intense hunger. If that freedom is called free will, I think it ordinarily exists.

But that can also be understood as two wills—the wish to eat and the wish to refrain for health—with the latter prevailing then.

Why did that person strongly develop the wish to refrain for health?

That returns me to the same place.

When debating free will, one side may ask whether we can act on desires while the other asks whether we freely made the desires themselves.

The conversation then never meets.

It’s free will in the latter sense that I deny.

What do we observe when we say strong-willed?

Thinking about this also makes judgments of strong and weak will feel strange.

Ten hours of daily studying attracts the label, but ten hours of games rarely does.

We see behavioral results, not how much pain, interest, fear, or anxiety moved the person.

Yet we give that result the name willpower.

I examine the expression in “What are we seeing when we call someone strong-willed?”

Even the causes of ordinary effort aren’t easily visible from outside.

Can crime really be explained simply as a bad person choosing badly?

Why was that person able to do it?

Seeing someone commit a crime, we usually ask:

Why did you do that?

That’s the usual question.

Another one occurs to me.

Why was that person capable of it?

There are many crimes I couldn’t commit.

For some, it isn’t goodness restraining a known bad choice. The action barely even appears among my options.

Asking ourselves makes this clearer.

Are you continually resisting the temptation to commit serious crimes?

Wanting to kill but enduring it daily, wanting to hurt someone but desperately suppressing it through reason?

I think many people aren’t.

The desire scarcely exists in the first place.

At least I don’t feel I’m making special daily efforts to avoid serious crime.

Did I create the self who doesn’t want to commit it through effort?

I didn’t design my desires, fear, empathy, pleasure, and pain one by one after deciding to become this person.

Yet some people can perform those acts.

Others may live while suppressing strong impulses ordinary people scarcely have.

Beyond the word character, there must be countless causes: temperament, home, education, body, relationships, successes, failures, finances, and circumstances at the time.

Of course I don’t know why any particular offender committed a crime.

Even identical offenses may arise through different paths.

Still, I feel fairly sure they didn’t design themselves from nothing and consequently become offenders.

Before anger, then, comes a question:

What path brought this person here?

That’s what occurs to me.

At the extreme, I can even feel some pity.

Unchosen characteristics or desires demand restraint others don’t need. If restraint fails and they hurt someone, society naturally imposes major restrictions.

Ordinary people aren’t fighting that battle to begin with.

Attributing the entire difference between my non-offending self and an offender to character or willpower feels wrong to me.

This doesn’t minimize the harm of crime.

Understanding causes doesn’t erase victims’ injuries.

Pitying an offender and letting them remain free are separate matters too.

Having causes doesn’t mean leaving someone unchecked

It may be tempting to infer no need for punishment from no free will.

But if returning someone to society poses a high risk of further harm, society must stop them.

Lack of free will doesn’t stop a blade piercing a body.

Restrict freedom to protect others from a dangerous person. Separate them from society if necessary.

That reason remains.

Its meaning changes a little.

Instead of saying they freely chose evil and therefore deserve suffering,

we don’t completely know how they came to this, but returning them outside endangers someone, so their freedom is restricted for now.

It becomes closer to that.

Intervene to prevent the next victim, not to return suffering to an evil person.

Harsher punishment doesn’t necessarily improve the future

Does making prison painful help?

Experiencing a disadvantage makes some people avoid repeating an action. Punishment can, I think, become a cause changing future behavior.

But greater suffering doesn’t necessarily mean less reoffending.

The US National Institute of Justice’s research summary also connects deterrence more strongly with certainty of being caught than severity, and notes that prison experience may worsen recidivism.

Increasing hatred of society while sending someone back with criminal skills and relationships would make suffering a failure as prevention.

If the aim is protecting society and reducing future crime rather than revenge, the questions change.

How much freedom to restrict? What learning opportunities to create? What happens without housing or work after release? Which causes need changing to avoid a return to the same conduct?

Punishment becomes a question of reducing future harm through institutions rather than how much pain to inflict on bad people.

Reflection becomes investigating causes rather than blaming myself

Reflection changes meaning too.

Often it contains the feeling:

I chose wrongly then, although I could have chosen correctly.

That’s a large part of it.

But identical conditions producing the same action seems more natural to me.

Does that make reflection pointless?

No.

Reflecting itself becomes a cause changing the next self.

What did I react to? What triggered it? What could change so the same situation doesn’t produce the same action next time?

Reflection approaches causal analysis rather than self-condemnation.

Look at the past to change the future self, not punish the old one.

Denying free will doesn’t erase responsibility

The idea of no free will may itself change conduct.

Someone previously stopped by guilt might do wrong more easily after deciding it isn’t their fault anyway.

Then the idea itself becomes a new cause.

We can’t end with no free will, therefore no responsibility.

If causes move people, we need more consideration of how education, laws, punishment, family environments, and poverty can change to reduce unwanted behavior.

If crime increases in an environment, don’t stop at a claim of declining ethics. Look at what changed to produce more of the action.

Denying free will seems to erase responsibility.

I see something slightly different.

What weakens is responsibility of this kind:

You’re bad, so suffer.

What remains is responsibility of this kind:

This action caused harm. Intervene here to prevent the next harm.

Responsibility doesn’t disappear.

Its justification changes from revenge to addressing causes.

Then feeling superior becomes uncomfortable

This stops being only about criminals.

An unpleasant shop assistant, an ineffective worker, someone unable to keep studying or stop drinking.

Before asking why they can’t manage even that,

I gain another question: why can I do it when they can’t?

That question appears.

It’s the same one I asked about crime.

Some things I do normally required no restraint from me in the first place.

Often, I didn’t become who I am through defeating powerful desires.

I could simply do it naturally.

It wasn’t particularly painful to begin with.

Perhaps I only later interpret that as being strong-willed or decent.

The idea that naturally acquired abilities are exclusively my own achievement also begins to wobble.

Then superiority feels uncomfortable.

Looking back, I think I’ve been very lucky. People sometimes liked me readily; things came naturally; those traits often brought further opportunities.

But I didn’t design them from the beginning.

Not wanting crime, continuing something naturally, or being easily liked can’t all be credited entirely to me.

Perhaps I’m another temporary phenomenon emerging from countless causes.

That doesn’t turn no free will into indifference toward responsibility for me.

Instead, it strengthens the habit of asking, about myself and others, why this result occurred.

Understanding a cause may let me change the next one.

No free will and nothing making a difference are separate claims.

After writing this, I asked AI to check typos and received the objection that I hadn’t disproved metaphysical free will.

I then investigated metaphysics itself and brought the difficult language back to concrete claims, recording the process in “I investigated metaphysics, and found that side falling apart instead”.

A further note: free will certainly exists as an experience

Another part of my thinking is that reality is what I actually experience.

An outside explanation can’t erase what someone experiences. I set this out in CORE: the ideas behind Mugen no Hamon.

It may sound contradictory, but in that sense free will certainly exists: I experience choosing for myself.

Hesitate, think, decide on this. Unlike involuntarily closing my eyes against bright light, I feel I’m choosing by my will. Experiencing it makes it unmistakably my reality.

The mechanism producing that choice is another question. Even a complete causal explanation through body, memory, and surroundings wouldn’t erase having thought and chosen.

Causes don’t make the experience fake. Denying free will doesn’t require denying what I certainly experience.

Virtual reality wouldn’t erase pain within it either. I discuss that in “Other people don’t exist. Perhaps this is virtual reality. Getting punched still hurts”.

Why does the same subject produce the opposing answers of free will existing and not existing?

The shared words conceal different questions.

Did I create this will independently of preceding causes? Do I experience choosing? I answer no to the first and certainly yes to the second.

Removing that distinction and demanding a single yes or no doesn’t yield one answer.

This connects with no single right answer in CORE. I don’t assume one answer for everyone without deciding what’s being asked or the purpose of considering it.

That doesn’t resolve every disagreement on the same question as a different viewpoint. These two are trying to establish different things from the outset.

After all this writing, honestly, I increasingly feel either answer is fine.

Not settling it doesn’t change what’s available in daily life.

Even without free will, a better physical condition makes action easier; different information and surroundings change thought. And I experience living while thinking and choosing.

For now, that’s enough.

If examining causes helps me understand myself and others, I can use that perspective. Proving or disproving free will itself isn’t my objective.

Thinking about making today more enjoyable interests me more now than pursuing that question endlessly.

Whether the Earth is round or flat doesn’t matter to me.


Reference: National Institute of Justice, “Five Things About Deterrence”

About the author

I made a major-label music debut and got results in sales and online business. After years of heavy drinking and debt, I now earn my living through deliveries while writing.

Why does life feel easier now than when I was getting those results? I tell the story of how I got here in Episode 0.

Uncategorized

コメント