Not Pretending to Understand What I Don’t: Knowing My Ignorance

霧の先へ分かれる夜の道路を歩道橋から見つめる人物 Uncategorized

As I’ve experienced different situations, occupied different positions, and kept writing about them, I’ve begun thinking about the phrase “knowing one’s ignorance.”

Put simply, it has become harder to make sweeping declarations.

When I try to say something is right or people should do it, I feel a hesitation I didn’t previously have.

It isn’t that I understand nothing. Thinking more closely has made a boundary visible: this much seems reasonably supportable, but beyond here I don’t know.

Looking back, that feeling itself isn’t new.

When I started this blog, Mugen no Hamon, I already understood that other people and I live under very different conditions.

So I didn’t make it a place to teach rules of success or recommend my way of life. I describe what happened in my body and life and what I thought about it. Readers decide what to do with it.

The same approach appears in CORE, the underlying thinking of Mugen no Hamon: this isn’t a place for teaching success formulas or imposing my views.

I couldn’t previously explain as clearly why that form of publishing suited me.

Continuing to consider food, alcohol, work, medicine, solitude, marriage, and happiness has made the old feeling seem close to knowing one’s ignorance.

Moving what was right for me onto someone else

A familiar principle says we shouldn’t impose our view even when we think it correct. I don’t disagree.

What I’m considering is slightly different. Rather than merely refraining from imposing a correct theory, applying it to someone else can make its correctness itself uncertain.

I’ve tried eating once a day for a long time. At some points, it made my body lighter and work easier.

That doesn’t establish that humans should eat once a day.

Someone whose condition stabilized after returning to three meals might conclude that three meals are fundamental. Their experience may be genuine too.

The problem comes afterward. “This suited me” is a long way from “therefore it suits you.” With different bodies and lives, changing the subject changes the claim.

Food additives offer another example.

Someone may feel better after reducing processed food and avoiding additives. We needn’t deny that experience.

But declaring additives poisonous and something everyone must avoid expands the claim dramatically.

Were additives alone responsible? Did the overall dietary change matter? Would another person experience the same thing? The assertion becomes much less simple on examination.

Is living freely better?

Work is similar.

Someone leaves packed commuter trains, management by a boss, and fixed company hours for self-employment. They ask why anyone remains a corporate wage slave and recommend quitting to live freely.

For them, it may be true. If employment was painful and independence made life enjoyable, they can strongly conclude that leaving was good for them.

But their experience can’t simply be transferred to another person.

Some find freedom in handling schedules, finding work, and managing income themselves. Others find that a serious burden. A set salary and reasonably defined tasks can be easier.

The rails that look restrictive from outside may actually be comfortable for them.

The reverse applies too. Someone’s difficult self-employment doesn’t establish that ordinary employment is best for everyone.

I feel similarly about marriage and children.

Some become happy through marriage; others become free through divorce. Children introduce some to previously unknown happiness, while others are satisfied without them.

Expand the subject to whether people should marry or have children, and I don’t feel able to decide what is right.

A different spouse can mean an almost entirely different life. A good relationship may change in ten years, and someone happy alone now may change their mind later.

Narrowing conditions permits some prediction. Creating a universal answer remains difficult.

The body makes things even less certain

Health and treatment are harder still.

Modern medicine, Western medicine, Eastern medicine, natural remedies; vegetarian, carnivore, low-carbohydrate, high-carbohydrate, one meal, three meals: there are many approaches.

When one improves our condition, we may want its theory to explain the entire world.

Humans should eat meat. Plants are better. Medication only treats symptoms. We shouldn’t trust weak evidence.

A single theory explaining everything is clear and attractive. I’m drawn to such explanations too.

Reality rarely seems to fit so neatly.

An approach explains one range well but struggles under changed conditions. What helps one person helps another little. That happens routinely.

Time adds another problem. Something initially worsening may improve later; something initially helpful may develop problems over prolonged use.

The term “healing reaction,” sometimes used to explain deterioration after beginning a regimen, illustrates that difficulty.

Temporary worsening during eventual improvement can occur in some contexts; equally, the method may simply not suit the person.

If every deterioration is explained as healing, the theory becomes right whatever happens. Yet instantly declaring failure after a small adverse change can also be premature.

How much observation is enough to judge?

I can compare days or weeks to some extent. A year or ten years is different.

Age, work, and environment change too. I can’t create two identical versions of myself and give them different diets for ten years.

I have one life. Careful observation still has limits.

I used to intervene much more

These thoughts affect relationships as well as writing.

If a close relative drank daily, smoked, and often ate processed food, the former me would probably have readily presented my theories.

I would also have wanted to contradict people taking three meals for granted or insisting on vegetarianism because meat was unhealthy.

If they developed a serious lung or stomach disease, I might have said I’d warned them, blamed lifestyle, and urged them to learn the lesson and stop drinking or smoking.

I’m quite different now.

I don’t know how far I can establish what caused that particular illness.

Alcohol and tobacco have well-established health risks. Even so, I can’t externally identify every cause of a particular individual’s lung cancer.

Meal frequency and particular foods, processed food, meat, or vegetables make the question still less straightforward.

I may suspect an influence. It remains my inference.

So even when I think I see a likely cause, I generally wouldn’t say anything unless asked.

Is remaining silent heartless?

Perhaps that can look heartless.

Someone with strong health convictions may find it wrong to watch family drink, smoke, and eat what they consider harmful without intervening.

If you care, stop them. Waiting for illness is too late. How can you watch a known danger silently?

I understand that feeling; I used to be much closer to it.

Often it comes from goodwill rather than a wish to control. I see danger they don’t, so I should tell them and, preferably, make them stop—especially if I care about them.

Now, I trust that very premise, that I see the correct answer, less than before.

Values also matter greatly in health.

People intensely interested in health may find this hard to believe, but some genuinely prefer a somewhat shorter life to one without alcohol.

If longevity requires losing favorite food, drink, and pleasures, they don’t know what they’re living for.

More people than expected hold that as a considered outlook, not merely a momentary temptation.

For now, I’m near the opposite end. I prefer a light body, a functioning mind, and comfortable everyday experience to one night’s pleasure drinking.

I removed alcohol to protect everyday pleasure, not reject pleasure. I explained that in “A true hedonist lives quietly”.

But that also reflects what I value most in life.

Even strong knowledge that a habit harms health doesn’t by itself establish that this particular person should stop. They may value drinking today over maximizing healthy lifespan.

I can regard that as foolish from outside. I don’t know whether it is truly wrong within their life.

Knowing a health answer doesn’t mean knowing the answer for a life.

I’m not denying goodwill. I don’t want to convert my preference into righteousness supposedly for another person’s sake. I also discussed that in “Giving up on being perfectly good made life much easier”.

Since thinking this through, I’ve stopped trying to correct others out of goodwill.

It may look like standing by. To me, it is less indifference than a much narrower estimate of how much I understand about another person’s life.

I make strong decisions for myself

I don’t intend to make my own life vague.

I’ve decided not to drink. That doesn’t mean recommending the same to someone else.

Recently, I also decided not to become deeply involved with habitual drinkers.

Alcohol’s effects on my body and life seem substantial. Considering how I want to arrange my life, that distance currently fits best.

It remains my choice. I’m not recommending everyone avoid close relationships with drinkers, nor trying to stop someone else drinking.

I simply chose the path I currently consider best for my life.

I don’t believe it as eternal truth. I observe present conditions and choose what appears likely to work, as explained in “Ultimately, I don’t believe in anything”.

That doesn’t contradict caution about other people.

I know my own body and experience to some extent. If the result is bad, I can bear it and revise. That lets me decide strongly.

Try saying the same about someone else, and suddenly information is missing.

I can say what I’ll do. Add “therefore you should too,” and the basis becomes much weaker.

A conclusion about myself already includes myself as a condition. Remove it and transfer the theory, and despite its similar appearance, it becomes a substantially different claim.

Live as you choose

Mugen no Hamon generally doesn’t recommend a way of life.

I describe what I did, what happened, and what I thought. Sometimes I state it strongly, but I don’t extend that conclusion directly to all humanity.

That has been my instinct since starting the blog. Now it connects with knowing my ignorance.

More experience and closer thought for writing haven’t made me understand everything. They’ve revealed more boundaries beyond which I don’t know.

I might previously have forced those into a single answer. Now I don’t feel I have to.

I decide my life. You can live yours as you choose.

That may look dismissive or heartless. For me now, it is a natural conclusion.

It isn’t only respect for freedom. I don’t know enough about another person’s body, values, or future life to determine their correct answer.

I won’t pretend to understand what I don’t.

That is close to what knowing my ignorance means to me now.

Later, an unfamiliar technical term briefly drew me toward authority before I removed the name and returned to specific claims. I described that example in “Being told it was metaphysics made me investigate—and that was what fell apart”.

About the author

I made a major-label music debut and got results in sales and online business. After years of heavy drinking and debt, I now earn my living through deliveries while writing.

Why does life feel easier now than when I was getting those results? I tell the story of how I got here in Episode 0.

Uncategorized

コメント