I used to think much more about living rightly than I do now.
Don’t inconvenience people. Hurt others as little as possible. Consider more than my own interests. Put into words, it’s ordinary enough.
But once I started thinking about it, I couldn’t stop halfway.
A slaughter video made even eating a question
One event especially triggered this: watching a video of animals being slaughtered.
Can humans live without harming others? More broadly, without sacrificing other living things? Those questions reached into every meal.
I did actually live without animal products then. I practiced a brown-rice vegetarian diet, and later spent a year eating only white rice, tubers, and a little seaweed.
That may surprise people who know only my current meat-centered food. I’ve actually tried avoiding animal foods too.
But changing what I ate didn’t end the questions.
We kill and eat huge numbers of cattle, pigs, and chickens while calling dogs and cats family. I understand cultural and emotional differences. Still, I began asking what standard determined the relative weight of lives.
Why does a human life weigh more than an ant’s?
Greater intelligence? Then how do we treat differences between humans? The ability to suffer? Then how much weight belongs to which organisms?
Calling humans special because we’re human is easy, but isn’t that simply humans treating themselves as special?
I thought some clean answer would eventually appear. The more I thought, the opposite happened.
Changing food doesn’t make a life without burdens possible
However far I went, human convenience remained at the end.
I can’t live without eating. Building a home takes another creature’s space. Clothes, electricity, medicine: none of it is completed by me alone.
Avoiding animal products didn’t let me live without consuming or burdening anything.
Choosing one thing also means not choosing another. Time helping one person can’t be spent on someone else.
Expanded this far, the goal of living perfectly well itself stops working.
I’m not saying all choices cause equal harm. Outcomes differ. But reducing burdens didn’t satisfy me; I was asking whether every burden could be eliminated.
Living means consuming something and drawing part of the world into maintaining oneself. Life itself seemed structured that way.
Why isn’t “because I want to” enough?
That also made the word altruism feel strange.
Acting for someone else is treated as beautiful; acting for oneself can be treated as ugly. But are the two so neatly separable?
I may help because I can’t bear leaving someone in trouble, because I want to be someone who helps, or simply because I want them to feel better.
Choosing to help doesn’t mean I don’t care about them. They may genuinely benefit, and that gives me no reason to reject the act.
But must I erase my own wishes and feelings from it to think of it as entirely for someone else?
“I’m doing it because I want to.”
I began to think that could be enough.
The same applies to acting for future humanity. Wanting to leave something so people a hundred or a thousand years ahead won’t suffer may produce wonderful results.
But I won’t see that future or know what its people truly want. If I still want to act, wanting to leave that future should be reason enough.
The moment it becomes something everyone ought to do for future humanity, my wish becomes public justice.
A value arose inside me, yet I stop recognizing it as mine. I think that was what bothered me.
I extend the same structure to nature and the planet in “Is ‘good for the Earth’ really the Earth’s own value judgment?”
I couldn’t pretend not to see contradictions
Perhaps people are more self-interested than we think. Perhaps that’s fine.
I used to resist admitting it. Maybe acknowledging that I lived for my own interests felt like losing something precious.
It was the reverse. Refusing to admit it hurt more.
I have selfish desires and also don’t want to hurt others. Sometimes I want to help people in trouble. I find animals cute and currently eat meat too.
Trying to combine all of that in one tidy theory always caught somewhere. I wasn’t good at pretending not to notice the catch.
People who can naturally draw a line and stop thinking beyond it can probably live normally that way. I couldn’t.
Eventually, I could see only two options.
Die, or give up being perfectly good and continue living as I was.
I saw no middle ground.
Eating consumes, and existing burdens other creatures or someone’s labor. Trying nevertheless to meet a condition of causing no sacrifice at all led me to question whether being alive itself was wrong.
Now I see that the condition was the problem. I didn’t have to meet it to live.
I gave up on perfect goodness and chose to live.
Without perfect goodness, I can still help when I want
Discarding the impossible goal of existing without hurting, taking, or burdening anything made life much easier.
That doesn’t mean deciding anything goes. I don’t want to cause suffering deliberately, and avoiding preventable unhappiness in front of me feels better. I may help someone I want to help.
I simply no longer need to do it to become a good person. I do it because I want to.
Likewise, I needn’t shoulder things I don’t want merely because they’re called duties to humanity, society, or others.
Strangely, removing perfect goodness as a condition didn’t make me want to live badly. I simply needed less self-justification.
I don’t trust myself as an unchanging admirable character either. I discuss people changing with conditions and living with that understanding in “Ultimately, I don’t believe in anything”.
I don’t need saving humanity as a reason to live today
Ultimately, I can see only from my own viewpoint. Once I die, I won’t perceive the world afterward.
I’d rather enjoy today than suffer under an obligation to perfect society a century ahead.
If I want to leave something for the future, help someone, or make something, I will. “Because I want to” is enough for all of it.
I don’t want to neglect the future either. Enjoy today while expanding tomorrow’s choices. I explain my present aims in “If you’re successful but unhappy, that’s failure: what success requires for me”.
There was a time when I thought humanity hopeless. Now I don’t think people need to be so admirable.
Like animals, we’re born, eat, move, desire, fight, sometimes help someone, and eventually die. Thinking of us as roughly that kind of creature simplifies things considerably.
I live for my own reasons. Someone may benefit as a result; some days I’ll be useful to nobody. That’s fine.
I’ve let go of perfect goodness, perfect correctness, and the obligation to save humanity.
Instead, while I exist, I’ll live with as much interest and good humor as I can. That’s enough for me now.
These ideas about correctness and living for oneself also appear in CORE: the ideas behind Mugen no Hamon. Here, I wrote about the thinking that led to them.
My path through music, sales, blogging, and the present life is recorded in Episode 0.


コメント